Its official, my Etsy shop is closed.

I went through my numbers today and since numbers do not lie, I decided to deactivate the rest of my items, half of which were going to expire in the next week anyway .

I found that I had made a whopping  $151.85  after deducting all the Etsy bills I had paid. I could not believe it. I had something like 45 orders and a total of 365 bucks in sales, but once I deducted the 174. and change bills and fees, I was left with 151.85 for all my hard work this year. If you have never had an Etsy site, I can assure you, it is work. I have to take a lot of pictures of each item, to insure five good pictures, the amount I am able to put on the listing. I have to keep in mind also, all the other things I spent money on, tools, bead baggies, a professional scale for the sequins, and some vintage sequins I purchased at a good deal to resell. If I add all that up, I lost money. I did not even break even.  I actually lost money this year. Big . Time.

On most items, you have to do research as well, checking what the going price is, so you can come up with a fair price. You have to have measurements and other information on your item and then have to fill out the forms they give you, then do your actual listing and description. It takes hours when you do a bunch of listings in a day. You pay 20 cents at the time you list it, then  you pay a percentage to Etsy for the sale, and then either they, or pay pal get more for the credit card fee. In many cases, they made more profit than I do, as I had to pay for the material I am selling.

I have come to the conclusion that if you are not selling items for minimum between five and ten bucks each, it is  not worth your time. Unless you are high volume, but I was not.

You have to figure in all the time to list that item, than you have to store it, then you have to pack and mail it, which takes at least another ten minutes of time to print out the packing slip and shipping label, let alone drive to the post office and drop it off . Forget minimum wage, I made pennies on the dollar for most of the things I sold and that was just making back what I paid for it all now that I look back. It is very heartbreaking.

If effort = good results, I would be making great  money. However. I have put in hundreds of hours in my studio the last few years for virtually nothing.

So, I will just blog what I am working on for myself and friends and family, and forget being in business for now. I just do not know anymore what to do. This last year was just selling supplies, so I did not even have the extra labor of creating items to sell, but still had to sort through, count, and do all the other steps needed to list each item. Until I did the numbers today, I thought I was doing well. It is hard to realize I made nothing and in fact lost money.

I have all the stuff I bought, so technically I did not “lose” anything, but I did not make a profit after all my expenses so business wise I made nothing and lost money.

My husband David and I have some ideas up our sleeves, so we will see what we decide to do. Whatever it is, it it will not be on Etsy more than likely.


So, time to let it go, and regroup. Not sure what I will do next, but be sure I will be sharing it here !!!

I will figure out a way to sell the old vintage sequins, but I still have a good amount of them, probably 90 percent or more !!!






2 responses to “Its official, my Etsy shop is closed.

  1. Oh Stephie, I am so sorry. If it’s any consolation, your business journey has influenced me right now. I opened an Etsy store awhile ago, but my husband became ill and I never was able to get it going. I had reservations when I looked at all the finished jewelry being sold and beautiful one of a kind things going for practically nothing. I can’t imagine these stores are making much of a profit if any. Knowing all the work you put into your store makes me think twice and three times in venturing into Etsy. I will keep tabs on you and looking for your posts as your positive nature and energy inspire me. Thank you for sharing.


  2. I am happy if I saved you from going through the same thing. Back when I started on Etsy in 2008 , it was much smaller and you got seen by people. I have actually put in searches that should bring my items up, and there are not enough pages shown to have my items show up. It will show you how many results, but when you get to the last page, and count the items per page, they did NOT show all of the items for that search. The number of pages and items per page, did not match up to the number of items they said were a match.
    I would list a really pretty key necklace. I would use a really pretty vintage key, add charms and beads and it would be 45 pages in, but a simple key, that was not even pretty like mine were, on a simple ball chain would be on page one. No creativity at all. It was very disheartening. That is why I started to sell mostly supplies instead of jewelry, with just a few exceptions. It just was too painful to spend all that time making items, putting my heart and soul into it, and they sit there. No sales.
    They want you to pay for advertising. I am not going to do that. They already get a listing fee, and selling fee and then another fee for using the pay service. As I mentioned, on my smaller items, they make more money than I do and that is not right at all. I wanted it to work so badly, but unless you sell items that are ten bucks or more, and actually sell them, it is just not worth it for the average person.
    Hey, it is cheap if someone wants to try. Another person might just have that great idea that sells. For me, nope. I would never discourage someone from trying, but there has to be a better way.Most people , especially in the handmade jewelry industry are not making much money.


I would love to hear what you think !!!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s